Mortgage broker · St. Augustine

Buying a home in St. Augustine: what to know before you buy

St. Augustine is the oldest city in the country, founded in 1565, and buying here can mean anything from a century-old house a few blocks from the Castillo to a beach cottage on Anastasia Island. It’s also three tax setups, not one. The City of St. Augustine, the separate City of St. Augustine Beach, and the unincorporated county around them all bill differently, and the old city adds two things most of Florida does not: real flood history and historic-district review.

NMLS #563819 · Company NMLS #1982611 · Licensed in FL, PA, TX

City, beach or county

Downtown and the historic neighborhoods. Walk to the bayfront, St. George Street and Flagler College. Neighborhoods like Lincolnville have houses from the 1800s and early 1900s, which means character, and also the flood and historic-review questions below.

St. Augustine Beach and Anastasia Island. Across the Bridge of Lions: beach town living, Anastasia State Park, and its own city government and tax rate.

The county around them. Newer neighborhoods west and north of the city, more space for the money, and the lowest of the three tax setups.

Three tax setups

AreaCity rateTotal millsTax on $600,000, homesteaded
Unincorporated St. Johnsnone13.456$7,547/yr · $629/mo
City of St. Augustine Beach2.5015.956$8,919/yr · $743/mo
City of St. Augustine7.5019.486$10,855/yr · $905/mo

St. Johns 2026 certified rates: county 5.3603 (general, road, health), fire district 1.47, schools 6.264, mosquito control 0.1553, water management 0.1793, FIND 0.027. The City of St. Augustine is outside the county fire district and provides its own. Some areas also carry a port, waterway and beach district levy or a local MSTU, which are not included here.

The city is about $276 a month more than unincorporated county on the same house. That buys city services, and it belongs in the comparison from the start.

Flood history

The city says 90% of its residents live in a floodplain. Hurricane Matthew in 2016 brought flood levels up to base flood elevation through most of the city, Irma flooded the same areas in 2017, and Nicole put water in the downtown streets again in 2022. On an older house, ask for the elevation certificate and a flood quote before your inspection period ends; on many downtown homes it is the line that decides affordability. If you plan to renovate, the city applies the 50% rule: improvements costing half the structure’s value or more require bringing it up to current flood standards. More: how Florida insurance escrow works.

Historic districts

Most exterior work in the city’s five historic preservation districts needs a Certificate of Appropriateness before a permit is issued, and demolishing any structure 50 years or older anywhere in the city needs its own certificate. If your plans for the house include a new roof line, windows or a porch, find out what review it needs before you price the renovation. A renovation loan can fund the work, but the review can add time.

Rentals

The city does not allow nightly rentals in its RS-1 and RS-2 residential zones, and allows only monthly or longer rentals in HP-1. If rental income is part of your plan, check the zoning before the contract, not after.

The seller’s tax bill is not yours

Florida’s Save Our Homes cap limits how fast a homesteaded owner’s assessed value can rise: 3% a year or the inflation rate, whichever is lower. When the house sells, the cap comes off, and the property is assessed at market value as of the January 1 after you buy. A seller who has owned for fifteen years can be paying tax on a fraction of today’s value.

That’s why I plan your payment on the purchase price rather than the listing’s tax figure, with your homestead exemption applied once you file. The appraiser’s market value often lands somewhat below the price, which makes this the conservative number. File homestead by March 1 of the year after you move in: how homestead and Save Our Homes work.

Amendment 3 passed on November 3, 2026

Florida voters approved Amendment 3 with about 62% of the vote; it needed 60%. Starting January 1, 2027, the homestead exemption against non-school property taxes rises to $150,000, then to $250,000 in 2028, with inflation adjustments after that. School taxes keep the $25,000 exemption. Save Our Homes and portability don’t change. For second homes and rentals, the yearly cap on assessment increases for non-school taxes drops from 10% to 5%.

When you get the larger exemption depends on when you became a Florida resident. If you’re a resident by December 31, 2026, it applies once you buy and file for homestead. If you arrive on or after January 1, 2027, you start with the standard exemption and the larger one begins in your fifth year of homestead, to the extent the U.S. Constitution allows.

The first tax bills affected are November 2027’s. The figures on this page are 2026 bills under the old exemption, and I’ll update them when 2027 rates are set. I qualify you on the tax you’ll pay in your first year.

Common questions about buying in St. Augustine

What are property taxes on a $600,000 house in St. Augustine?

With homestead, about $629 a month in unincorporated St. Johns County, $743 in the City of St. Augustine Beach and $905 in the City of St. Augustine.

Do I need flood insurance in St. Augustine?

If the house is in a special flood hazard area and you have a mortgage, yes. The city says 90% of its residents live in a floodplain, so ask for the elevation certificate and a flood quote before your inspection period ends.

Can I renovate a house in St. Augustine’s historic districts?

Most exterior work in the city’s five historic preservation districts needs a Certificate of Appropriateness before a permit is issued. Improvements costing half the structure’s value or more also have to meet current flood standards.

Can I rent out a St. Augustine house nightly?

Not in the city’s RS-1 and RS-2 residential zones, and only monthly or longer in HP-1. Check the zoning before the contract.

The same $600,000 house, nine places

Property tax and any CDD assessment count in your debt-to-income ratio and your escrow, so they change the price you qualify for as well as the payment.

AreaTotal millsTax per month, homesteaded
Ponte Vedra Beach (St. Johns)13.456$629
Nocatee, St. Johns side, before CDD13.456$629
St. Augustine Beach15.956$743
Atlantic Beach17.112$796
Nocatee, Duval side, before CDD17.653$821
Kernan, UNF and Mayo Clinic area17.653$821
Neptune Beach17.728$824
Jacksonville Beach*18.357$853
City of St. Augustine19.486$905

Assessment at the price, with homestead. *Jacksonville Beach uses its proposed 2026 rate. Without homestead (a second home or rental), add roughly $40 to $70 a month.

Other Northeast Florida areas: The Beaches and Ponte Vedra · Nocatee · Kernan, UNF and Mayo Clinic area · All of Jacksonville

Figures use 2026 millage as adopted or certified where available; rates still marked proposed or tentative are labeled. Tax estimates assume assessment at the purchase price with the standard homestead exemption for 2026 ($51,411 against non-school levies, the second $25,000 now indexed to inflation; $25,000 against school levies) and are planning estimates, not tax bills. CDD assessments are the district’s published FY2027 amounts and vary by parcel. Flood zone and insurance cost depend on the specific property.

Let’s talk about your St. Augustine purchase

Send me the house you are looking at, or the address you are thinking about. I’ll come back with the real tax, any CDD, the insurance picture and real wholesale pricing. No pressure, and no credit pull until you say so.

Prefer to talk? Call or text me directly at (412) 302-1919.