First-Time Home Buyer

First-time home buyer mortgages in Pennsylvania, Florida and Texas

If you’re a working professional buying your first home, this page covers the decisions that matter: how much to put down, when to lock, what to do about points, how much cash to keep in reserve.

I’ve been originating mortgages since 2003, and I’ve closed dozens of loans for first-time buyers in Pittsburgh and across Pennsylvania, Jacksonville and the Beaches, and statewide in Florida and Texas.

What’s Actually Different This Time

What is different for a first-time buyer?

A few things are different the first time around, and they’re worth knowing in advance. One route that comes up more often than people expect is buying a 2–4 unit and living in one of the units — it is financed as a primary residence, not as an investment property, so the down payment and the rate look nothing like an investor loan.

The pre-approval has to happen before the offer. In a competitive market, the seller won’t even look at an offer without a current pre-approval letter from a real lender. Not a “you might qualify” prequalification from a website — a full pre-approval with documented income, assets, and credit. Once you send complete documents, I usually turn the pre-approval around within 24 hours — so how fast this moves depends mostly on how organized your documents are.

Your real estate agent matters more than you think. A good agent helps you avoid bad houses, structures offers that win without overpaying, and protects you during inspection. A bad agent costs you tens of thousands. If you don’t have one yet, ask people you trust. I work with agents in FL, PA, and TX and I’m happy to introduce you to ones I know are good.

The inspection is worth it. The seller’s listing photos are marketing. A licensed home inspector tells you what’s wrong with the house — and the inspection period is your only real chance to walk away or renegotiate. Spend the $400-$700. It’s the highest-ROI line item in the entire transaction.

Closing day is anticlimactic. You’ll sign a stack of documents (most of which look terrifying, most of which are routine), wire the funds, and walk out with keys. The actual emotional moment is usually two days later when you’re standing in an empty house wondering why you bought a place with this much wall space.

None of that is complicated. But the first time around, knowing what to expect removes the anxiety that drives bad decisions — like overpaying because you’re worried you’ll never get another offer accepted, or skipping the inspection because you want the deal to feel “easy.”

The Math That Actually Matters

The questions worth wrestling with — and the ones to ignore.

For most first-time buyers in the professional category, four decisions drive the financial outcome of the purchase. Here’s how I think about each.

How much to put down. The “you must put 20% down” rule is outdated. Conventional loans are available with 3-5% down for first-time buyers, and at strong credit scores the PMI cost is modest. The real question isn’t “do I have 20%” — it’s “should I deplete my savings to avoid PMI, or keep cash in reserve and pay PMI for a few years until equity builds?” The right answer depends on your job stability, your other expenses, and what else that cash could be doing. We’ll model both.

Whether to buy points. Discount points let you pay upfront to lower your interest rate for the life of the loan. The break-even math is straightforward — points pay off after a certain number of years, depending on the size of the rate reduction and the cost of the points. If you’ll own the home longer than the break-even, points win. If you might sell or refinance before then, they don’t. I show the break-even on every quote. The same applies to adjustable-rate mortgages: they are cheaper right now, and I will show you the worst-case payment at the cap before you decide.

How much cash to keep in reserve. Buying the house is half the conversation. The other half is what you have left after closing. The rule of thumb I use with first-time buyers: three to six months of total housing payment (principal, interest, taxes, insurance, HOA if applicable) sitting in liquid savings after closing — minimum. If you can’t hit that and still have the down payment you want, you’re buying too much house. That’s a hard sentence to hear when you’ve found “the one,” but it’s the honest one.

30-year vs 15-year vs something in between. The 30-year fixed is the default for a reason — lowest payment, maximum flexibility. The 15-year is appealing because the rate is lower and the payoff is faster, but the monthly payment is significantly higher and the lost flexibility costs more than people expect. I generally recommend 30-year for first-time buyers, with the explicit intent to make extra principal payments when cash flow allows. You get the lower required payment, you control the payoff timeline, you keep flexibility if something changes. We can run the math both ways.

“The biggest first-time-buyer mistake isn’t choosing the wrong rate. It’s buying too much house and ending up with no financial margin. The mortgage is the easy part. The eight years that follow are where things go wrong.”

What you can mostly ignore: rate predictions, “buy now before rates go up” pressure, and any conversation that starts with “you’re throwing away money on rent.” Rent is the cost of optionality. Owning is the cost of commitment. Each makes sense in different seasons of life. Whether you’re in the right season is a real question worth answering before you start shopping — our rent vs. buy calculator runs the honest break-even, with maintenance, taxes, and opportunity cost included.

Down payment assistance.

In Florida, I do Hometown Heroes. It’s Florida Housing’s down payment program for first-time, income-qualified buyers, and for 2026 it’s limited by occupation: at least one borrower has to work full time for a Florida-based employer in health care, K-12 schools, first response, public safety, the courts or child care, or be a service member or a veteran working full time for a Florida-based employer. It pays up to 5% of the first mortgage, from $10,000 to $35,000, as a 0% second mortgage with no monthly payments. It comes due when you sell, refinance or move out, and it isn’t forgiven. It’s funded in rounds, so I’ll check whether money is available when we talk. Who qualifies for Hometown Heroes, and how the repayment works.

In Pennsylvania, I don’t offer assistance programs. If your income qualifies for one, I’ll tell you and point you to a lender who does them, because for the right buyer they’re worth more than a small difference in rate. The main ones:

City of Pittsburgh (URA): up to $7,500 if household income is below 80% of the area median, or up to $5,000 between 80% and 115%, as a 0% deferred loan on a home inside the city. A HUD-certified homebuyer course is required.

PHFA K-FIT: 5% of the price as a second mortgage, forgiven 10% a year over ten years, paired with PHFA’s Keystone Home loan.

PHFA Keystone Advantage: 4% of the price or $6,000, whichever is less, repaid at 0% over ten years.

Most of these programs are income-capped and come as a second mortgage, so they aren’t free money. If you qualify, they’re often the better deal.

The Honest Answer

When should a first-time buyer wait?

I’d rather lose a deal than help someone buy a house at the wrong moment in their life. A few situations where the honest answer is to wait:

If you’re moving in less than three years, the transaction costs of buying and selling will eat any equity you build. Rent the cheap apartment, save the difference, buy when you’re staying put — the rent vs. buy calculator shows you the break-even for your own numbers.

If your industry is in a layoff cycle — and you know it is — buying right now adds a fixed cost to your life at the exact moment you’d want flexibility. If your job feels stable enough to commit a 30-year mortgage to, great. If it doesn’t, wait six months and see how things land.

If your down payment would zero out your savings, the house is likely too much for now. Houses break. Roofs leak. Water heaters die. Property tax bills surprise people. If you have no liquid cash after closing, you’re one bad month from a credit card crisis. Either buy less house or save longer.

If you’re buying because you feel like you “should,” it’s worth pausing. The best time to buy is when the math, the house and the timing all work, regardless of what friends or family are doing. The cost of waiting a year is almost always lower than the cost of buying the wrong house at the wrong time.

Most of the time, the honest answer for a working professional is some version of “yes, this makes sense, here’s how to do it well.” Sometimes it’s “wait.” If your scenario is the second one, I’ll tell you.

Common Questions

The questions first-time buyers ask.

How much do I need to bring to closing?

Down payment plus closing costs plus prepaid items. Closing costs typically run 2-3% of the purchase price, depending on your state and lender choices. Prepaid items (initial escrow for taxes and insurance, prepaid interest from closing date to month-end) add another 1-2%. So on a $400,000 home with 5% down, you’re looking at $20,000 down plus roughly $12,000-$20,000 in closing and prepaids — call it $32,000-$40,000 total. Lender credits and seller concessions can reduce that significantly. In Pennsylvania, realty transfer tax is often the single biggest closing-cost line — you can estimate it by county and municipality with our PA transfer tax calculator. If the home is in an HOA, add its one-time fees on top — here’s how an HOA affects your loan and closing. You can also build your own cash-to-close estimate — down payment, closing costs and prepaids together, minus your deposit. We’ll give you a real number based on your scenario, not a “starting at” estimate.

Should I get pre-approved before I look at houses?

Yes. Two reasons. First, in any active market, sellers won’t seriously consider offers without a current pre-approval letter from a real lender. Second, getting pre-approved forces you to confront what you can afford before you fall in love with houses you can’t. The pre-approval is free and doesn’t obligate you to use me — but you’ll be glad you did it before you start touring.

What credit score do I need to buy a house?

There are two numbers here. The minimum to qualify is 620 for a conventional loan and 580 for an FHA loan with 3.5% down — and below those floors, buying is often still possible, which I break down in can you get a mortgage with a low credit score. The score that prices your loan is a different — and more important — number, and it is usually not the one on your credit-card app. On conventional financing your credit tier steps up every 20 points: 620, 640, 660, 680, 700, 720, 740, 760, and 780. 780 is the top tier — nothing improves above it, and the old notion that 740 is as good as it gets stopped being true when the pricing grid was overhauled in 2023. Those steps are real money: moving from a 698 to a 700, or a 738 to a 740, can lower both your rate and — if you’re putting less than 20% down — your monthly PMI, which is also priced by score. For a first-time buyer at 3–5% down, your credit score is usually the single biggest lever on your monthly payment. So the honest guidance: above 740 you’re in strong shape and I wouldn’t delay a purchase to chase points. But if you’re sitting just under a breakpoint, a month or two of paying down your credit-card balances before you apply can pay for itself many times over. Tell me your scenario and I’ll tell you exactly which tier you’re in, whether you’re a few points from the next one, and whether it’s worth the wait. I’ll run that math for you.

Do I have to put 20% down?

No. 20% down lets you avoid PMI, but you don’t need it to qualify. Conventional loans go as low as 3% down for first-time buyers. The right down payment isn’t a fixed number — it depends on your cash position, what else that money could earn, and how long you’ll keep the loan. For many professional first-time buyers, 5-10% down with a few years of PMI works out better than 20% down with no cash reserves.

What’s PMI and when does it go away?

Private mortgage insurance — required on conventional loans when your down payment is less than 20%. It protects the lender, not you. The good news: PMI is removable. Once your loan-to-value reaches 78-80% (through payments, appreciation, or both), you can request removal. For a typical purchase, that’s usually 4-7 years out, faster if home values appreciate.

How long does the process take?

Pre-approval: usually within 24 hours of receiving your complete documents. House shopping: variable. Once you’re under contract, my standard close target is 30 days. Florida and Texas can sometimes do 25 days. Pennsylvania runs 30-35 due to how PA handles title and recording. I’ll give you a realistic timeline once we know your specifics.

What’s the difference between pre-qualified and pre-approved?

Pre-qualified means you filled out a form and a lender said “based on what you told us, you’d probably qualify.” It carries little weight in a competitive offer. Pre-approved means a lender has reviewed your income, assets, and credit and committed to a loan amount subject to the appraisal and final underwriting. Sellers know the difference. Get pre-approved, not pre-qualified.

Should I lock my rate or float it?

Lock once you’re under contract, unless there’s a clear reason not to. Rate timing is unpredictable and the downside of being wrong is usually larger than the upside. Some lenders offer “float-down” options if rates drop materially after you lock — worth asking about, especially in a volatile rate environment. I’ll explain the tradeoffs on your specific quote.

Can I use gift funds for the down payment?

Yes. Gifts from family members are allowed on most loan types, with documentation requirements — a gift letter, source-of-funds verification, and sometimes a paper trail from the giver’s account to yours. Plan the gift timing carefully. Money that shows up in your account two days before closing creates problems. Money that’s been there for 60 days doesn’t. We’ll walk through the documentation when we talk.

What if I’m self-employed?

You can absolutely qualify for a mortgage as a self-employed borrower — the documentation is just different. Conventional loans typically require two years of tax returns plus year-to-date profit/loss statements. Bank statement loans are an option for borrowers whose tax returns don’t reflect actual cash flow. The underwriting takes more work but the rates can be similar to W-2 borrowers for strong scenarios.

Do you offer first-time homebuyer assistance programs?

In Florida, yes: Hometown Heroes, for buyers who work full time for a Florida-based employer in health care, schools, public safety, the courts or child care, and for service members and veterans. In Pennsylvania, no. If your income qualifies for a program there, such as the City of Pittsburgh’s URA assistance or PHFA’s K-FIT, I’ll tell you and point you to a lender who offers it.

Ready to start?

Let’s figure out what your first home looks like — in real numbers.

Two ways to start. Talk it through with me first if you want to think out loud about whether this is the right time. Or send me your scenario and I’ll come back with actual pre-approval numbers — purchase price range, down payment options, what your monthly payment would look like at a few different price points. No pressure.

Talk First

Text or email with whatever’s on your mind — house you’re considering, questions about whether you’re ready, curious how this all works. I’ll respond within one business day. No pressure.

Or Get Real Numbers

Tell me your scenario — target purchase price, down payment plans, FICO range, your state — and I’ll come back with actual numbers. No credit pull until you say so.

Request a Rate Quote →