Why one lender’s cash-to-close can look smaller than another’s
If you’ve gotten Loan Estimates from a few different lenders, you’ve noticed they don’t look apples-to-apples — the rate might be similar, but the bottom-line “cash to close” can vary by thousands. Some of that difference is real. Some of it comes from estimates that look better on paper than they will at closing — and borrowers often don’t see the gap until the Closing Disclosure arrives. Here’s what’s happening, and how to read a Loan Estimate so you don’t get caught.
I quote this way for every buyer, in writing and side by side: in Florida (Jacksonville, the Beaches and statewide), Pennsylvania (Pittsburgh and Western PA) and Texas.
What lenders control vs. what they don’t
A Loan Estimate has three categories of charges, and they’re treated very differently under federal regulation:
1. Charges the lender controls directly (Section A on the LE)
These are things like origination charges, discount points, lender credits, and underwriting fees. The lender quotes these and is legally required to honor them at closing within strict tolerances. If they quote $1,200 in origination, they can’t show up to closing with $1,800.
2. Charges the lender doesn’t control, but is closely connected to (Sections B and C)
These are services where the lender picks the vendor — title insurance through their preferred title company, appraisal through their AMC, credit report fee, etc. The tolerance depends on the section. Services you can’t shop for, like the appraisal and credit report in Section B, generally can’t go up at closing at all. Services you can shop for but picked from the lender’s list, like title in Section C, can rise by up to 10% in total before the lender has to cover the difference. Preferred is not required, and on title it is worth knowing the difference: what you can shop on your title bill.
3. Charges the lender doesn’t control at all (Sections E, F, G — taxes, government recording fees, prepaid escrows, homeowners insurance)
These are the property taxes, the daily interest from closing to first payment, the homeowners insurance premium, the months of taxes and insurance the lender collects upfront for the escrow account, and the government recording fees.
This is where most of the difference between quotes shows up.
How estimates lower the cash-to-close
Property taxes and homeowners insurance estimates on a Loan Estimate are technically “estimates” — and the lender isn’t required to use accurate numbers. They’re required to use reasonable numbers, but “reasonable” is a wide range.
A lender who wants their Loan Estimate to look more attractive can do any of the following:
- Quote property taxes based on the seller’s old assessed value instead of the new buyer’s likely reassessed value
- Use the lowest homeowners insurance estimate available rather than what you’ll pay
- Underestimate the months of prepaid escrows required at closing
- Quote outdated transfer tax or recording fees if state/county rates changed
- Use a generic per-day interest figure that doesn’t match your actual closing date
Each of these adjustments lowers the “Estimated Cash to Close” number — sometimes by $3,000 to $8,000 — without changing anything the lender controls.
By the time you get to closing, the Closing Disclosure shows the real numbers. The taxes are higher. The insurance is higher. The escrow setup is more. And by then, you’re 30 days in. You’ve spent on inspections and appraisals. You’ve planned your move. You can’t easily walk away over $5,000. When that day comes, the stack in front of you — and which pages deserve a line-by-line read — is covered in signing your loan documents.
How to read an LE so this doesn’t happen to you
When you’re comparing Loan Estimates side by side, ignore the “Cash to Close” number at the bottom. It depends the most on estimates and is the least useful for comparison.
Instead, focus on the lender-controlled section:
Section A — Origination Charges
This is the most important number on the LE. It includes:
- Origination fees
- Discount points (if buying down rate)
- Application fees
- Underwriting fees
- Any other fees the lender themselves charges
This is what the lender is being paid for the loan. Two lenders quoting the same rate should have similar Section A totals if they’re priced competitively. Big differences here mean one lender is charging you more than the other for the same loan. Our Loan Estimate comparison tool isolates exactly this — it strips out the escrow noise so you can line up Section A and the rate across every quote.
Lender Credits
A lender credit is a negative charge — the lender gives you money to offset closing costs in exchange for accepting a slightly higher rate. Real credits, transparently disclosed, are fine. They’re a useful tool.
What’s not fine is when a lender shows a credit on the LE but then it shrinks at closing. That happens occasionally, and it’s a red flag about who you’re working with.
Compare those two things across all your LEs. That’s the apples-to-apples comparison.
What to ignore in the side-by-side
Sections B, C, E, F, and G — title, taxes, insurance, prepaids, recording — should ultimately be roughly the same across all your Loan Estimates if the lenders are using accurate numbers. They’re for the same property, same closing date, same insurance, same taxes.
If one lender’s tax and insurance numbers are dramatically lower than the others, that usually means their estimates are low, not that they’re more efficient.
What I do differently
When I prepare a Loan Estimate for a client, I use the actual local property tax rate based on the new assessed value. I use a real homeowners insurance quote — not a placeholder. I calculate prepaid escrows based on the actual closing date. The numbers I quote at the start are the numbers you’ll see at closing, within normal small adjustments.
That sometimes means my LE looks like it has a higher cash-to-close than someone else’s. But the gap usually closes by closing, because the lower estimates rise to the real numbers.
If you’re shopping mortgages and you’re not sure how to compare offers, send me what you have. I’ll look at the LEs side by side and tell you what they mean. Even if you don’t end up working with me, you’ll know what you’re looking at.
Common questions
How do I compare Loan Estimates from different lenders?
Compare the rate, Section A origination charges and any lender credits across all your Loan Estimates. Section A is what the lender is being paid for the loan, so two lenders quoting the same rate should have similar Section A totals if they are priced competitively. The Cash to Close number at the bottom depends the most on estimates and is the least useful for comparison.
Why is one lender’s cash to close thousands lower than another’s?
Often it comes from the estimates the lender does not control, such as property taxes, homeowners insurance and prepaid escrows. A lender can lower the Estimated Cash to Close, sometimes by $3,000 to $8,000, by quoting taxes on the seller’s old assessed value, using the lowest insurance estimate or underestimating the months of escrow. The Closing Disclosure then shows the real numbers.
Can a lender raise its fees between the Loan Estimate and closing?
Charges the lender controls directly, in Section A, must be honored at closing within strict tolerances. Services you can’t shop for, such as the appraisal, generally can’t increase at all, and services you can shop for but picked from the lender’s list, such as title, can rise by up to 10% in total. Taxes, insurance, prepaids and recording fees are estimates the lender does not control at all.
Is a lender credit on my Loan Estimate a good thing?
A real credit, transparently disclosed, is a useful tool: the lender gives you money toward closing costs in exchange for a slightly higher rate. A credit that appears on the Loan Estimate and then shrinks at closing is a red flag about who you are working with.
Who can look over my Loan Estimates in Jacksonville?
I can. Send me your Loan Estimates and I will compare them side by side and tell you what each one means, even if you do not end up working with me. I quote buyers in Jacksonville, the Beaches and statewide in Florida, as well as in Pennsylvania and Texas.
I’ll compare them for you, even if you don’t end up working with me.
Email or text me your LEs and I’ll tell you what each one means, where the estimates may be low, and what to ask each lender to clarify.
Request a Rate Quote →